The Spanish Grand Prix, Time For A Reality Check…

This was supposed to be a post about how Fernando Alonso and Ferrari bounced back from Bahrain. I had a really snappy title for it, which was: Mercedes Fades, Vettel Loses His Wings, And Alonso Rewrites History… How through bold strategy, a perfectly timed pit stop call, and a car that seems to have the pace in all situations, they delivered an inspired result. How Fernando executed a drive that was nothing less than exceptional and to prove yet again why he is the most complete driver on the grid.

Fernando Alonso comes from 5th on the grid to claim victory-sadly no one cared...

Fernando Alonso comes from 5th on the grid to claim victory-sadly no one cared…

However, instead of me going on about Fernando’s brilliance, I have to spend what will seem like a week blogging about the tires, how bad they are, how the sport is being ruined, and that four pit-stops is somehow a F1 sacrilege. Or how Vettel and the RB9 can’t race to their true potential (news flash: they raced as true to their potential today as they did in Bahrain, one race they won, one they did not). Or how when Lewis Hamilton starts second but ends up 12th then there is surely something wrong. That when drivers are driving at 70% of their potential, somewhere along the way F1 made a wrong turn. Hopefully you can sense my sarcasm between the lines. News flash: Alonso and Ferrari race at 100% of their potential why didn’t any one else?

The web is already lit up with fans saying “F1 RIP”, “the sport is a farce”, “racing is a joke”, “Pirelli should be fired”, “I turned the TV off half way through”, and on and on and on. While online, I came upon a comment on my favotite site,  James Allen on F1. By the time I got to his site after the race 300 comments (and still counting) were already posted to give you an idea of the scope of the displeasure of the F1 fans. The comment turn out to be a re-post from Will Buxton. I am going to share Will Buxton’s thoughts on the matter, which I am in complete agreement with, and I might have to write a couple more blogs to set people straight until I get to write the blog I really want to write. The one about how Alonso stole the show, is simply in a class by himself, how Ferrari got it right, and that when Fernando has a well balanced car he is unstoppable. Shucks, even when the car is not well balanced, out of balance, half balanced, doesn’t balance at all, can’t be balanced, Fernando can still deliver the goods. Yeah I can’t wait to get to that post, but whatever…

Will Buxton - NBC pitlane reporter on right had many things to say after the spanish GP. I liked them all...

Will Buxton – NBC pitlane reporter on right had many things to say after the spanish GP. I liked them all…

Without any further delay here is a reprint of Will Buxton’s thoughts after the Spanish GP, from his blog

I loved the Spanish Grand Prix. Every lap of it.
I jest not. I loved. Every. Single Lap.
You may ask why, with the world at large seemingly set on berating another race in which tyre strategy played too large a role. I hope I can go some way to explaining myself.
Earlier in the weekend I had a fabulous conversation with a driver in the paddock. I didn’t record it as it was just two friends chewing the fat, and he probably wouldn’t want me to quote him anyway. So please forgive the paraphrasing.
“Mate, everyone is complaining about the tyres. But the guy who wins… does he complain? No. You should ask them why they don’t complain when they do well, when the day before they were saying it was the end of the world. The only one who understands it is Kimi. He says it’s the same for everyone. If you don’t like it, **** off, do something else. He’s right. If you make the tyres more durable and you only have three stops in a race everyone will still try to make only two stops. It’s the same now as it was with Bridgestone. You always try to do one less stop. By complaining you only damage the sport. It’s the same for everyone. Get on with it and race.”
I loved the opinion. I loved the candor.
There’s nothing more depressing than standing in the pen at the end of the race and asking a driver how his day went, and how happy he must be with his result, only to get an answer that racing to a delta is boring and gone are the days of pushing during a race.
So ask yourself. What did Ferrari do on Sunday?
Did they drive to a delta? Did they try and make one fewer stop than their rivals? Did they hell. They went out and they pushed. Every. Single. Lap.
Fernando Alonso’s opening stint was mesmerising. He was running quali laps on full fuel. It was an absolute joy to behold. And while he might not have been putting in quali laps all day, he certainly wasn’t hanging around.

What Ferrari did in Spain was to completely flip the script. Rather than going into the race and telling their drivers to hold back, they told them to push with everything they had. Four stops was always their intention and it caught everyone else off guard.
Red Bull realised what was going on too late and switched from three stops to four, but by then the race had already been won.
Formula 1 loves a villain and this year Pirelli has been cast into this pantomime role. But, as I explained at the end of the Spanish Grand Prix in my final thought on the NBC Sports Network, the job of a Formula 1 team is to design a car around the variables which are unchangeable. Hermann Tilke used to get the blame for ruining the show for his apparently dreadful circuit design. But is it not the job of the teams to design a car for the circuits on which the championship races? Of course it is. Just as it is the job of the teams to design a car that maximizes the tyres on which it runs.
The problem we’ve had of late is this unfortunate trend towards the creation of a formula based upon the misheld belief that preservation is a better mode of attack than consumption.
What Ferrari showed in Barcelona was that yes you may have to make more pitstops than we’ve seen in the past, but that it is possible to push from the moment the lights go out to the moment that the flag falls. That so much of the press is decrying the race shows, I believe, a disappointing cynicism. Pirelli has become too easy a target.
But should we blame Pirelli for simply doing what they’ve been asked to do and make the tyres less durable? Or should we blame the teams who have seemingly got themselves into the rut of a blame culture that hides the true fact that some have not designed a car capable of maximizing one of the unchangeable variables that has defined the history of the sport?
Because this is nothing new.

I remember with great fondness an interview I conducted with Sir Stirling Moss about a decade ago about his greatest races. And the one that always sticks in my mind is his explanation of how he won the 1958 Argentine Grand Prix. He lined up in a privately entered Cooper and against the might of Ferrari he won, taking the first F1 victory for a mid-engined car in the process. How he did it holds as much relevance today as it did back then.
The tyres were only good for 30 laps. 40 tops. The race was 80 laps long. You couldn’t finish without stopping for new tyres. The Cooper’s tyres were fixed with studs, rather than the quick hammer release nuts on the Ferraris. Moss couldn’t win with such a long pitstop delta to change a studded wheel.
He pulled into the lead but nobody paid it any attention. He’d have to stop and all would be lost. But he didn’t stop. He carried on. And by the time Ferrari figured out he wasn’t going to stop, it was too late. The pack gave chase, but Moss won… by 2.7 seconds from Luigi Musso. His tyres were down to the canvas. He’d been driving on the grass for the last few laps to try and cool them down.
“Was I brave that day or stupid?” Moss confided in me. “To this day I don’t know as the two were very closely related. I did everything you shouldn’t normally do to win that race.”

In a way, and although actually completely the opposite of Moss’ fabulous Argentine win in that Ferrari made more stops than expected, that’s precisely what the Scuderia did on Sunday. Because they did everything that, apparently, you shouldn’t normally do on Pirelli tyres to win the race.
They actually raced.
As the Moss story highlights, trying to make fewer pitstops has always been a part of F1. It is nothing even vaguely new.
But, for me, the 2013 Spanish Grand Prix was a game changer. Ferrari’s victory was the perfect riposte to those who claimed that Pirelli’s tyres could not be raced on. Does anybody now have the excuse of saying that it is impossible to push in a race on these tyres, when Ferrari showed that for 66 laps you could… and that by doing so you could win?
With the exception of Lotus the other teams have every reason to feel frustrated after the Grand Prix, as do their fans. Ferrari showed what was possible. It is now up to everyone else to react. For while it might not be achievable for everyone at every race to do what Ferrari did today, what they proved is that Formula 1’s greatest misconception is that doing so at all was impossible.
That’s why I loved the Spanish Grand Prix.

he goes on to say :
Think about it for a minute.         It’s why you should have loved it too.

very well said Mr. Buxton, very well said…     -jp-

2 Comments on “The Spanish Grand Prix, Time For A Reality Check…

  1. All in all a great result in terms of the championship. Both Alonso and iceman closing the gap to Vettel. Ferrari and Lotus seem to have great race pace and Alonso and iceman are on top form. To beat the Vettel/RedBull combination, others will have to be very close to perfection. I don’t really care who wins the WDC if we can have great racing between great drivers like Alonso, Kimi and Vettel (to be honest I want iceman to win).

    I agree with most of your points regarding the tyre “issue”. I didn’t see the Bulls complaining that much when they (Vettel to be precise) were dominant in Bahrain. And this is not a new problem for the Mercs. Their cars have been eating tyres in races for how long now? 2 seasons? 3 seasons?

    But, to be honest, my opinion is that tyres played little too bigger part this weekend. I’m not taking anything away from Alonso’s brilliant victory – he totally deserved it and I think even if iceman did a 4-stopping race, Alonso still would have won. But when drivers of Hamilton’s caliber start the race 2nd and finish 12th without any car failure or a change in weather, there must be something wrong somewhere. Even a Merc cannot be that bad surely? And when you hear the likes of Vettel being asked not to race others (including Kimi), I find it a little bit odd.

    But, I do believe that Barcelona is an exception as it’s a track that is known to be unkind to tyres. Personally I would like to see a race where a 3-stopper is able to run pretty much all out attack while a 2-stopper can try an alternate strategy with a bit of tyre saving. But that’s just how I like it.

    And as you say, I don’t really get why people are blaming Pirelli for this. They are just doing what they are being asked to do by the FIA. In some forums I have read people saying they will stop buying Pirellis for their road cars because of this fast degradation. That is plain ridiculous as the road tyres are totally different from the racing tyres. But I won’t be surprised if Pirelli give in to all this pressure and make their F1 tyres more durable and conservative. At the end of the day, they are mainly in F1 for brand recognition. They wouldn’t want to harm their reputation.

    P.S. – good read as usual

    • hey Tom, after reading your comment, it got me thinking about something that i might have overlooked. i have been viewing this issue from the point of “is red bull justified in their complaint.” i, as do quite a bit of people feel they are not. it is the decisions that they took over the break in their design that is root cause of their problems. but what i have not been thinking about is the point of view from the fans. and in that context you and a very large part of the F1 community might very well have a point. maybe pirelli has gone just a little bit to far. cheers for re focusing my attention. jp

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: